Top 10 Pizza in Fayetteville Arkansas

November 05, 2023

Looking for the Top 10 pizza in Fayetteville Arkansas?  College towns are known to have great pizza joints, and Fayetteville, home of the famous Razorbacks at the University of Arkansas are indeed proud of their huge variety of pizza spots. Thin crust & wood-fired, deep dish hand tossed can all be found in Fayetteville.  Choose from the list below to experience some of the best pizza you’ve ever put in your mouth.

Best Pizza In Fayetteville AR

Damgoode Pizza Fayetteville Ar $$

37 E Center St, (479) 444-7437Love the name, don’t you?  With 3 different crust options and ample fresh toppings, this pizza joint makes a pizza that is beyond good, they are delicious.  Demand is high, so service may be a bit slow, but the pies are well worth the wait. There’s also a good selection of brews on tap.  Do yourself a favor and try one of the pies soon to see what all the buzz is about.  

Geraldi’s $$

20 S University Ave, (479) 575-0556

Not just a pizza house, but a restaurant serving delish antipasto salad, tasty pesto pizza, spicy shrimp alfredo, huge plates of pasta and other favorite Italian dishes.  The pizza is really very good and atmosphere lends itself to families, couples, singles or a group of friends. Parking is a bit of a challenge, but the effort is definitely worth it.

Marleys Pizza Fayetteville Ar $$

609 W Dickson St, # 103,  (479) 301-2815Marley’s offers more than a dozen specialty pizzas as well as a build-your-own option. Crusts options include hand tossed, Chicago-style and Gluten Free.  Sandwiches, salads, desserts and appetizers are popular menu items. Draft and craft are on tap, and bottled domestic and imported beer and wine are also available.  Service is excellent, and if you’re a sports enthusiast, Marley’s has plenty of TVs situated so you can watch the games. Image courtesy of Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar.

Mellow Mushroom $$

1460 E Augustine Ln, (479) 521-1001Serves awesome stone-baked pizza, delicious calzones, filling hoagies and crisp fresh salads.  It also has GF and lacto-ovo pizza and salads. Nice selection of specialty pizzas and a huge list of fresh ingredients for build-your-own, as well as a selection of sweet treats is on the meue.  The Mellow also offers delicious cocktails made from fresh ingredients and a large selection brews including some local favorites. Great spot for friends, family or colleagues to gather.

Mojos Pizza Fayetteville Ar $$

1200 Garland Ave #7, (479) 935-3459

Mojo’s has a fantastic atmosphere, great pizza menu, pasta and appetizers.  There’s live music from Wednesday – Saturday unless the Razorbacks are playing, and the drink specials are great too.  Happy hour, Tues – Fri, has $1 off drafts, bottles and wells. Happening spot to kick back and relax with friends. Image courtesy of Mojo’s Pints & Pies.

Tim’s Pizza Fayetteville Arkansas

1813 E Mission Blvd, (479) 521-5056A visit to Tim’s Pizza East is a delightful experience from the moment you pass through its doors.  The staff is friendly and eager to please. Tim’s offers delish appetizers and breadsticks, amazing gourmet pizzas including a GF version or you may build your own, killer sandwiches, wraps, 9 different salads and calzone.  The crusts are amazing and rather crisp and the mozzarella is delicious. Image courtesy of Tim’s Pizza East.

Wicked Wood Fired Pizza $

1946 N. Birch Street, (479) 466-8911 (multiple locations)If you are a crust aficionado, you must give Wicked Wood Fired Pizza food truck a whirl.  The crusts are crunchy, easy-to-chew sourdough, and they are awesome. The toppings, besides the high quality mozzarella, are fresh, as fresh as just-picked, and the house-made marinara sauce is divine.  Add to all this goodness the flavor of a wood-fired oven, and you’ve got a pizza to text about. The staff is great and the service is efficient and timely. Image at top of the page courtesy of Wicked Wood Fired Pizza.

Woodstone Pizza Fayetteville $$

557 S School Ave, (479) 444-1947Has a high energy vibe, and fast, professional service.  These are delicious craft wood-fired pizzas that are bursting with flavor due, in large part, to the unique (house ricotta, toasted cashews, scallions, pickled carrot & cucumber, seasonal fruit marmalade – to name a few), and fresh toppings.

Features a full bar staffed by trained mixologists who create absolutely divine cocktails.  A wide assortment of craft brews is on draft, and white and red wine, bottled beer along with non-alcoholic cocktails are also available. This is a great place to relax with friends and family while you enjoy a top-notch meal experience.  

There is a second Woodstone pizza location at 3619 Mall Avenue in the Uptown district.

Top 10 Lists For Fayetteville Arkansas